How did Singapore become the first to charge cars for driving into town?
Posted
Watch it
Video script
Singapore was the first country in the world to charge cars for driving into town. And back then, ERP was a piece of paper.
It started on the 2nd of June 1975, twenty-three years before ERP. Between seven-thirty and nine-thirty in the morning, a car going into the city centre needed a three-dollar licence from the post office, on the windscreen. An officer stood at every gantry, reading them. Drive in without one, and he wrote down your number plate.
It worked. In March, almost 43,000 cars drove in each morning. By August, about 11,000.
But there was a loophole. If your car had four people in it, you drove in free. No licence needed.
So drivers went looking for three more people, often at the bus stop. In the queue for the gantry, they'd signal how many they still needed, and commuters hopped in.
Fourteen years later, the free pass was scrapped. The minister told Parliament many car pools were just drivers picking up three passengers.
One driver remembers boys who waited just before a gantry. They'd ride through, hop out with a small tip, and walk back for the next car, right in front of the officers.
Next, the void deck, and why the ground floor of your block is empty.
Every fact, with its source (22)
22 facts. Tap a source to read it yourself.
The Area Licensing Scheme (ALS) began on 2 June 1975: to drive into the central business district's restricted zone, a motorist had to buy and display a special supplementary area licence.
The first restricted hours were 7.30 am to 9.30 am, every day except Sundays and public holidays.
The licence cost S$3 a day or S$60 a month for a private car (company cars S$6 a day).
Licences went on sale on 15 May 1975 at the Registry of Vehicles and 16 selected post offices.
The licence was a paper licence displayed on the windscreen (on the handlebars for motorcycles).
- Kian-Keong Chin (Land Transport Authority), "Road Pricing - Singapore's 30 Years of Experience", CESifo DICE Report 3/2005 ifo.de
- Kian-Keong Chin (Land Transport Authority), "The Singapore Experience", OECD/ITF Round Table on implementing congestion charges (2010) oecd.org
- The Straits Times, "Made In Singapore: ERP, the traffic solution pioneered by the Republic" (Teo Kai Xiang, 21 Mar 2025) straitstimes.com
Enforcement officers were stationed at the gantry control points during the restricted hours and checked by eye whether each vehicle showed a valid licence.
- Kian-Keong Chin (Land Transport Authority), "Road Pricing - Singapore's 30 Years of Experience", CESifo DICE Report 3/2005 ifo.de
- Kian-Keong Chin (Land Transport Authority), "The Singapore Experience", OECD/ITF Round Table on implementing congestion charges (2010) oecd.org
- The Straits Times, "Made In Singapore: ERP, the traffic solution pioneered by the Republic" (Teo Kai Xiang, 21 Mar 2025) straitstimes.com
Vehicles without a licence were not stopped at the gantry: officers noted the number plate and the owner was sent a summons.
The fine for entering without a licence was S$50.
When it started in 1975, Singapore was the only city in the world running a scheme like this; economists had proposed congestion pricing for years, and Singapore was the one exception that put it into practice.
- World Bank, "Relieving Traffic Congestion: The Singapore Area License Scheme, 1975", Number 053 (Aug 2006) documents1.worldbank.org
- Peter L. Watson and Edward P. Holland (World Bank), "Congestion Pricing: The Example of Singapore", TRB Special Report 181 onlinepubs.trb.org
- NLB Infopedia, "Area Licensing Scheme" (Lim Tin Seng, valid as of 15 Aug 2014) nlb.gov.sg
The ALS ran for 23 years until the Electronic Road Pricing (ERP) system replaced it; the ERP rules came into operation on 1 April 1998.
- NLB Infopedia, "Area Licensing Scheme" (Lim Tin Seng, valid as of 15 Aug 2014) nlb.gov.sg
- Kian-Keong Chin (Land Transport Authority), "Road Pricing - Singapore's 30 Years of Experience", CESifo DICE Report 3/2005 ifo.de
- SSO, Road Traffic (Electronic Road Pricing System) Rules 1998, S 176/1998 (in operation 1 April 1998) sso.agc.gov.sg
In March 1975, 42,790 cars a day entered the restricted zone between 7.30 and 10.15 am. In August 1975 it was 11,130, a fall of 74 percent. All traffic entering the zone in those hours fell by 40 percent.
Some motorists waited at the gantries for the restricted hours to end before driving in, so the restricted hours were extended to 10.15 am.
- NLB Infopedia, "Area Licensing Scheme" (Lim Tin Seng, valid as of 15 Aug 2014) nlb.gov.sg
- Kian-Keong Chin (Land Transport Authority), "The Singapore Experience", OECD/ITF Round Table on implementing congestion charges (2010) oecd.org
- Peter L. Watson and Edward P. Holland (World Bank), "Congestion Pricing: The Example of Singapore", TRB Special Report 181 onlinepubs.trb.org
Cars carrying at least four people (the driver and three passengers) were exempt from the licence.
- NLB Infopedia, "Area Licensing Scheme" (Lim Tin Seng, valid as of 15 Aug 2014) nlb.gov.sg
- Kian-Keong Chin (Land Transport Authority), "Road Pricing - Singapore's 30 Years of Experience", CESifo DICE Report 3/2005 ifo.de
- Peter L. Watson and Edward P. Holland (World Bank), "Congestion Pricing: The Example of Singapore", TRB Special Report 181 onlinepubs.trb.org
The car pool exemption was there to counter the charge that the scheme favoured only the rich.
An average of 2,137 car pools a day entered the zone between 7.30 and 9.30 am in May 1975, and 3,880 a day in August, an increase of 82 percent.
Drivers waiting in line to enter the zone would indicate how many people they needed to reach four.
In Parliament on 30 May 1989, an MP described people who "simply walk across the road" and get into a car heading into the CBD so it had four people and went in free.
In the same debate, the minister, Dr Yeo Ning Hong, said that previously many car pools had been "just drivers in cars picking up three passengers".
The car pool exemption was removed in June 1989 because private cars were picking up bus commuters instead of forming genuine car pools. From 1 June 1989 every road user paid except emergency vehicles and public buses.
- Kian-Keong Chin (Land Transport Authority), "Road Pricing - Singapore's 30 Years of Experience", CESifo DICE Report 3/2005 ifo.de
- Kian-Keong Chin (Land Transport Authority), "The Singapore Experience", OECD/ITF Round Table on implementing congestion charges (2010) oecd.org
- NLB Infopedia, "Area Licensing Scheme" (Lim Tin Seng, valid as of 15 Aug 2014) nlb.gov.sg
Kumar Balasingam, who got his driving licence in 1975, remembers picking up boys who waited just before the gantry, jumped into the car, jumped out just after it for a small tip, and repeated it, in view of the policemen stationed there.
A second, unsourced account says children waited by the road just outside the restricted zone and offered to be passengers.
42,790 to 11,130 is the 74 percent fall the World Bank authors give. June 1975 to June 1989 is 14 years. 2 June 1975 to 1 April 1998 is 22 years 10 months, which NLB and LTA's Chin both call 23 years.
- Our own arithmetic on the dates and figures above
More sources (5)
- eresources.nlb.gov.sg The Straits Times, 12 Jan 1977, p. 1, "RZ 'illegal' court shock" and "But it's carry on paying" (NewspaperSG issue listing)
- eresources.nlb.gov.sg The Straits Times, 30 Apr 1977, p. 5, "C J 'no' to plea for RZ appeal" (NewspaperSG issue listing)
- mot.gov.sg Ministry of Transport, "Electronic Road Pricing (ERP)" (ERP 2 roll-out complete and ERP 1 decommissioned on 1 Jan 2027)
- nas.gov.sg National Archives of Singapore, photograph "Restricted zone gantry at North Bridge Road on the first day of the Area Licensing Scheme" (SPH), 2 Jun 1975
- trid.trb.org Cho Kwang Soo, "ERP cuts congestion in Singapore" (1998), TRID abstract
Corrections
No corrections so far. Any correction to this video is logged here, with its date.
